On Mar 31, 1:54 pm, sky46...@trline4.org wrote:
> >Hi,
> >I have released the second official version of the gEDA Binary Suite
> >for x86 GNU/Linux. This binary suite has the following features:
>
> I have found KiCad more easy to work with. Too bad it ain't in google-summer..
Every package has its strengths and weaknesses (and I obviously have
my bias).
kicad is definitely more of an integrated suite and more newbie
friendly.
gEDA consists of less integrated programs (separate program working
together; a deliberate design choice). The ability to insert
arbitrary data manipulation at any point into the design flow allows
for lots of flexibility. However, this flexibly comes at a price (a
steeper learning curve). There is a strong user (and developer)
community and lots of FAQs/documentation to offset this learning
curve.
For a showcase of all the different projects out there created using
the gEDA suite, please take a look at: http://geda.seul.org/links.html#projects
-Ales
PS. The GSoC 2008 student deadline has been extended until Monday,
April 7, 2008!
--
Ales Hvezda
ahvezda AT seul.org
http://geda.seul.org
donald - 01 Apr 2008 03:10 GMT
> On Mar 31, 1:54 pm, sky46...@trline4.org wrote:
>>> Hi,
[quoted text clipped - 12 lines]
> arbitrary data manipulation at any point into the design flow allows
> for lots of flexibility. However, this flexibly comes at a price (a
And a big way to shoot off your foot.
> steeper learning curve). There is a strong user (and developer)
> community and lots of FAQs/documentation to offset this learning
[quoted text clipped - 12 lines]
> ahvezda AT seul.org
> http://geda.seul.org
Ales Hvezda - 01 Apr 2008 03:37 GMT
[snip]
> > gEDA consists of less integrated programs (separate program working
> > together; a deliberate design choice). The ability to insert
> > arbitrary data manipulation at any point into the design flow allows
> > for lots of flexibility. However, this flexibly comes at a price (a
>
> And a big way to shoot off your foot.
Yup. "Remember, with great power. comes great responsibility. " :-P
--
Ales Hvezda
ahvezda AT seul.org
http://geda.seul.org
sky465nm@trline4.org - 02 Apr 2008 20:47 GMT
>On Mar 31, 1:54 pm, sky46...@trline4.org wrote:
>> >Hi,
>> >I have released the second official version of the gEDA Binary Suite
>> >for x86 GNU/Linux. This binary suite has the following features:
>>
>> I have found KiCad more easy to work with. Too bad it ain't in google-summer..
>Every package has its strengths and weaknesses (and I obviously have
>my bias).
>kicad is definitely more of an integrated suite and more newbie
>friendly.
I have used gschem aswell. I like it too, but kicad seems to speed up the
workflow. In particular I like the 3D stuff of kicad. Which makes inductor
and connector pcb layout stuff easier to visualise and get right.
Something that I miss with geda/pcb is the ability to make new component
layouts smoothly.
>gEDA consists of less integrated programs (separate program working
>together; a deliberate design choice). The ability to insert
>arbitrary data manipulation at any point into the design flow allows
>for lots of flexibility. However, this flexibly comes at a price (a
>steeper learning curve). There is a strong user (and developer)
>community and lots of FAQs/documentation to offset this learning curve.
The dataformats of KiCAD is in text style. So it's easy to manipulate them if
needed.
>For a showcase of all the different projects out there created using
>the gEDA suite, please take a look at: http://geda.seul.org/links.html#projects
I know about them ;)