Years ago I saw a generator demo where you hand cranked the generator.
The thing used light bulbs as a load. First 100 watts, then 200, then
300, then 600. Cranking out 600 watts with only arm power is amazingly
hard.
ERS
I have a mechanical bicycle/generator which uses a permanent magnet DC
motor. I use this in a freshman Engineering class in order to
demonstrate how difficult it is to generate electric power. In the
class, I usually have 5 volunteers come down to ride for 2 minutes
each. I check the power output every 10 seconds and then I tell them
on average how much power they produced, and how long it would take
them, at that rate, to produce 1 kilowatt hour. Nobody every goes
beyond 250W. Most people generate about 125W to 150W (and this is only
for two minutes). So, I believe that there is no human being who can
generate 600W with one arm. 600W is what would be required to lift 438
lbs a distance of 1 foot in one second.
flank
Joel Kolstad - 27 Apr 2006 01:08 GMT
> So, I believe that there is no human being who can
> generate 600W with one arm.
You're correct, but simply moving a generator shaft where the output happens
to be connected to a 600W load doesn't actually produce 600W unless you manage
to turn the shaft at the generator's rated speed. :-)
Your number look like what I've seen before; athletic individuals can generate
a couple hundred watts for two minutes. Those guys who compete in the Tour de
France can manage four hundred watts for sustained periods; see
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human-powered_transport -- fascinating stuff.
---Joel
Rich Grise - 27 Apr 2006 22:56 GMT
>> So, I believe that there is no human being who can
>> generate 600W with one arm.
[quoted text clipped - 9 lines]
>
> ---Joel
When I was in high school physics, we were learning about this stuff, and
for a demo, they had a couple strapping lads volunteer to run up two
flights of stairs, as fast as they could, no rules - vault the handrails,
pull up while taking three or four steps at a time, just get to the top
as fast as you can - and they'd time the ascent. The height was known, and
either the guys knew their weight, or we might have weighed them. The
fastest/strongest guys just barely made 1 HP, and were exhausted at the
top of the stairs. It was so exhausting, even the spectators got winded! ;-)
Cheers!
Rich
Eric R Snow - 30 Apr 2006 22:18 GMT
>I have a mechanical bicycle/generator which uses a permanent magnet DC
>motor. I use this in a freshman Engineering class in order to
[quoted text clipped - 9 lines]
>
>flank
The way this thing worked you would use both arms to turn the crank.
At 100 watts you could turn the crank fast enough to brightly light
the bulb, at 300 watts the bulbs would start sorta bright and you had
to try real hard to get them bright enough for the thing to switch to
600 watts. At the 600 watt setting it was all I could do to turn the
crank and the light sure didn't get bright. I was also unable to turn
it more than a couple revs at that setting. I'm sorry that I left the
impression that I was cranking with one arm, or that I was able to
keep cranking at the 600 watt level. If you ever get to eastern
Washington State the demo is at one of the dams.
ERS